Wet vs Dry Aged Steak: What's Actually Better? The Results Shocked Me!

28-Day Wet vs 30, 45 and 60-Day Dry-Aged Strips

Wet vs Dry Aged Steak - Click to Watch Video

Looking to make better BBQ on your Kamado? Download my free “12 Mistakes Kamado Grill Owners Make” guide.

Introduction

Four Prime Strips, One Reverse Sear, Side by Side

What's up BBQ fans! Today I've got four bone-in prime New York strips, 16 oz each, and they're very different: a 28-day wet-aged, a 30-day dry-aged, a 45-day dry-aged and a 60-day dry-aged. I've been ordering dry-aged beef for years, but I've never compared them side by side. We're reverse searing all four on the Komodo Kamado 38.

Wet vs. Dry Aging

  • Wet aging means the meat sits in its own juices in the package, in this case for 28 days.

  • Dry aging means hanging it in a specialized fridge, sometimes with salt or UV lights, so bacteria and mold don't grow. It loses water weight and gets more tender and beefier. The longer it goes, the more of that "nutty" flavor people talk about.

A high-end steakhouse probably ages a minimum of 21 days, and so does a good butcher. Costco doesn't age its meat at all, and you can tell.

The Setup

  • Lit with the GrillGun (use code: RUMANDCOOK to save 10%). It makes quick work of any lump.

  • Fuel: Bear Mountain's brand-new premium hardwood lump charcoal, my first time using it.

  • Two zones. The basket splitter keeps the lump on one side. Grates go on the lower level over the fire for searing, and on the upper level on the indirect side for the reverse sear.

  • Vents: three turns open on top and the left half-moon bottom vent wide open to get it rolling, then dialed back. I put the steaks on at 225°F with the top opened just a hair.

The Seasoning

Keep it simple: Diamond Crystal kosher salt and fresh cracked pepper from the Pepper Cannon (use code: RUMANDCOOK to save 10%). Season from up high for even coverage. To keep track, I used toothpicks: one for the 30-day, two for the 45 and three for the 60.

The Thermometer

This was my first cook with the Typhur Sync Gold Dual (use code: RUMANDCOOK to save 10%). Typhur is a new partner, and here's why.

My Komodo Kamado walls are over 2 inches thick, my Yoder is 10-gauge steel, and my offset is 3/8-inch steel. Nearly every wireless thermometer I've tried has disconnected on me. The ThermoWorks RFX has been reliable, but it's bare-bones and needs a separate pit probe.

  • Each probe has six sensors: five internal, plus a ceramic ambient sensor at the tip. They're rated to about 932°F.

  • The base has its own display, so you don't need the app.

  • It's Bluetooth plus sub-1G, rated up to 3,000 ft unobstructed and 700 ft obstructed.

I put one probe in the 60-day, which should cook fastest since dry aging removes moisture, and the other in the wet-aged, which was a bit thinner. Then I sat in the yard with a rum and Coke and my dogs. I even walked out to a tree I later measured at 315 ft with my golf rangefinder. Not one dropout.

The Reverse Sear

About 30 to 40 minutes on the indirect side, targeting about 118°F. These were a good 2 inches thick. I like mine finished around 132 to 135°F. If you like it rare, drop your pull temp about 5 degrees.

Bone tip: the meat near the bone lags behind. I turned the steaks so the bone faced the fire and slid them up to the edge of the hot zone. I checked them with my Typhur InstaProbe, which reads in about half a second, and they were all 117.5 to 119°F.

Rest them about 15 minutes. With a reverse sear, you get about 5 to 7 degrees of carryover, and the sear adds a little more.

The Sear

I opened it up, pulled the top middle grate for access, and took the Sync probes out, since the grate was over their rating. The dome read 650°F, and my IR gun read about 1,000°F at the grate. A quick hard sear on all four.

The Verdict

  • Wet-aged: the juiciest of the bunch, with lots of flavor.

  • 30-day: noticeably beefier.

  • 45-day: even beefier. My favorite.

  • 60-day: the beefiness actually dropped off a touch, replaced by some other flavor. I'm no sommelier, but I think that's the "nutty" people talk about.

They were all about equally tender. The difference is the flavor profile.

Final Thoughts

For a special treat, I've always ordered 50, 60, even 70-day dry-aged. After tasting them side by side, I don't think the extra money is worth it. For me, it's the 30 or 45-day, and the 45 is my pick. If you're into steak, try some high-quality prime dry-aged beef. It'll ruin restaurants for you, but it'll be damn good at home.

Thanks For Watching

Whether you're a seasoned pitmaster or a novice, these tips will enhance your cooking skills and leave your family and friends raving about your delicious, smoky creations. Don't forget to subscribe to my YouTube channel for more step-by-step videos, and let's together become the barbecue heroes we were meant to be!

*Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. You will pay the same price, but I will earn a small percentage, which will help support the channel.

Previous
Previous

Perfect New York Strip on a Pellet Grill Every Time

Next
Next

7 Pellet Grill Secrets Every Beginner Should Know!