The Ugly Truth About Pellet Grills (10 Things You Should Know)
10 Things Nobody Tells You About Owning One
Looking for the maximum smoke flavor from your pellet grill? Download my free "11 Secrets to Maximize Smoke on a Pellet Grill" guide.
Introduction
The 10 Questions Every Pellet Grill Owner Asks
What's up BBQ fans! Whether you're shopping for a pellet grill or you just got one, these are the 10 things nobody tells you about owning it. They come from five or six years of comments, emails, Reddit threads and Google searches, and I've answered over 5,000 comments, so trust me, these come up constantly. Let's get into it.
1. Why Is My Temperature All Over the Place?
A pellet grill is a live fire, just like an offset. The controller adjusts the auger based on averages over minutes, not seconds, and no two pellet brands are the same size or shape. Some controllers claim zero swing. They're just hiding it from you, and a wireless thermometer shows the truth.
Every time you crack the lid or fiddle with the dial, the controller feeds more pellets and overshoots. I've watched my oven swing 40°F all night on a pork butt. That's normal. Set it and leave it. You will never outsmart the computer.
2. Why Doesn't My Food Taste Smoky Enough?
A pellet grill is a completely different animal, and nobody turns out amazing food on day one. I have over 500 cooks on pellet grills and my brisket is night and day compared to five years ago.
Add a smoke tube or wood chunks in the wood-fired cage on my Pitts & Spitts. Use quality pellets, because they're your fuel and your flavor. I've been on Bear Mountain for three years. The hotter the fire, the cleaner it burns and the less smoke you get, so for brisket I start at 180 to 200°F for at least four hours, then step up through 225 and 250 to 275°F. Skip the long stretch at 275°F and you'll get white pockets of unrendered fat.
3. How Do I Store My Pellets?
Pellets are compressed wood. Add water and they turn to mush, then dry rock hard. I learned that on my Yoder, when moisture got in the hopper, I left it three weeks, and the auger wouldn't turn.
Keep the hopper covered and stay out of the rain. I fold the bags over and keep them in my garage. Containers and sifting out dust are a waste of time. Moisture causes jams, not sawdust. If a pellet squishes between your fingers, don't use it.
4. Why Did My Pellet Grill Turn Off Mid-Cook?
That's a flame out. Clean out the firebox before every cook. On my Pitts & Spitts, for a long or hot cook I open the lid, set it to 250°F for 10 to 15 minutes to burn off the mess, and vacuum every three to four cooks. A dirty fire pot is the top cause.
High wind can do it too, so try rotating the pit 90 or 180 degrees. The other culprit is a pellet bridge, where pellets catch on the sloped hopper walls and stop feeding the auger.
5. How Often Should I Clean It?
Vacuum it out once a month, and clean the firebox before every cook. Four pork butts at once leave a ton of grease, and crank the heat afterward and you've got a grease fire. That's self-inflicted pain.
I stopped foiling the diffuser plate because it just rusted underneath. I clean the smoke stack with a toilet brush, and in spring and at season's end I deep clean with Zep 505 on the outside. I keep chemicals off the inside.
6. Do I Need to Do Anything Before My First Cook?
Yes, whatever the manual says. New grills have manufacturing oils that burn off with a terrible smell and taste. Do a burn-in of about three hours at 450°F. Then on stainless grates, spray a very light coat of cooking oil and run it a couple more hours, like seasoning cast iron.
7. Should I Cook by Time or Temperature?
Temperature, every time. There's no meat on the planet you can cook by time. Ribs can be done at 195°F or 203°F, and a chuck roast may finish at 205°F or 211°F.
My go-to is the Typhur InstaProbe (use code: RUMANDCOOK to save 10%). Probe it until it feels like warm peanut butter. For long cooks I also use the Typhur Sync Gold Dual, with two wireless probes and an ambient reading on my phone and watch.
8. Can I Run My Pellet Grill Overnight?
Yes. Set it at 180 to 200°F, fill the hopper, and 12 hours is easy. The goal isn't a finished brisket by morning, it's a nearly finished one with extra smoke and rendered fat. Then bump the temp to finish. Keep a gap between the smoker and your house and make sure your outlet is up to date.
9. Why Is One Side of My Grill Hotter?
It's common and it's part of learning your grill. My Yoder has a damper that slides across. My Pitts & Spitts has a slide-able deflector plate under the diffuser. Run a biscuit test if you like, then put the bigger pork butt in the hot spot so both finish together.
10. How Should I Shut Down My Pellet Grill?
Follow the manual. My Yoder and Pitts & Spitts both wind down on their own in 12 to 15 minutes. After a long or hot cook, I open the lid, set it to 200°F, and walk away for 10 to 15 minutes before closing it and hitting the power.
Never just unplug it. Fire can creep up the auger into the hopper, which is very dangerous. Let it run through the shutdown, even if that means an umbrella in the rain.
Final Thoughts
Pellet grills can turn out killer barbecue, but it's a craft. If you're looking to take your pellet grilling game to the next level, check out my Pellet Grill Mastery Bundle. Got questions? Drop them in the comments, because I answer every one.
Thanks For Watching
Whether you're a seasoned pitmaster or a novice, these tips will enhance your cooking skills and leave your family and friends raving about your delicious, smoky creations. Don't forget to subscribe to my YouTube channel for more step-by-step videos, and let's together become the barbecue heroes we were meant to be!
*Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. You will pay the same price, but I will earn a small percentage, which will help support the channel.
